|
Transition as a vehicle:
Moving from high school to an adult vocational service provider
Nuehring, M.L. & Sitlington, P.L.
Journal of Disability
Policy Studies
VOLUME 14, NUMBER 1, Fall
2003
Copyright© PRO-ED, Inc.
Reprinted with permission
Transition as a Vehicle
Moving From High
School to an Adult Vocational Service Provider
Michelle L. Nuehring, Cedar
Rapids Public Schools
Patricia L. Sitlington,
University of Northern Iowa
This qualitative research study examines
the transition of adolescents with autism from high school to adult
vocational service providers. The article looks at the current, ongoing
transition of a high school senior and also analyzes the transitions
made by three previous graduates. In so doing, it allows for a look
inside three separate vocational service providers, revealing both areas
of strength in the transition process across these providers and the
school and areas in need of improvement.
Transition-a simple-sounding word that
encompasses complex concepts. To understand the broader context of
transition, we must look beyond the professional literature and observe
the process firsthand.
This study examined the transition
experiences of four students with autism. Three of these individuals had
made the transition from school to work, whereas the fourth was in his
senior year of high school. In this article, we will examine the
transition process, the key participants, and the planning tools and
resources, and we will offer recommendations for improving the process.
We will also examine the extent to which our experiences resonate with
what has been described in the professional literature in the field.
According to the language of the
Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) of 1990 and the 1997
amendments to it, the term transition services refers to a coordinated
set of activities for a student with a disability that:
a) Is designed within an outcome-oriented
process, that promotes movement from school to postsecondary education,
adult services, independent living or community participation; and
b) Is based on the individual student's
needs, taking into account the student's preferences and interests (34
C.F.R. § 300.27).
Transition includes a multifaceted look
at the student and a variety of services. An ongoing process, transition
allows individuals an opportunity to collaborate with community agencies
and make meaningful career choices for their future. Transition planning
requires an outcome-oriented approach that looks at future vocational
placements, residential options, funding sources, and community
resources. For the purpose of this article, we will focus on the
vocational placements for students with severe disabilities,
specifically, the developmental disability of autism.
Initial Question,
Participants, and Site Selection
We conducted this research project on
transition to better understand the complexity of the process. We wanted
to see how the transition process in place was working and whether it
was doing all that it could for adolescents with autism. In order to
answer these questions, we chose to study transition from the standpoint
of a senior in high school. We also looked at three individuals who had
already graduated from high school. These students had been educated in
a classroom for students with autism at Central High School, through
which they each received some job training at community-based work sites
before graduation. Each of these students selected a different adult
vocational service provider to attend after graduation.
Data Collection and
Analysis
All observations and interviews were
conducted by one of the co-authors, who is also the classroom teacher at
the high school where all four individuals attended. Several
tape-recorded interviews were completed. These interviews contained
structured, open-ended, and depth-probing questions, as recommended by a
number of authors (Berg, 1995; Bogden & Biklen, 1992: Eisner & Peshkin,
1990; Glesne, 1999; Guba, 1990). The co-author spent many hours
observing at each of the three vocational service providers; she also
talked with the transition coordinator from each of these programs at
great length. Because the high school has a large impact on transition,
the co-author spoke with the work experience coordinator from Central
High. To fully understand the decisions and thought processes that
occurred during the transition, she also spoke with each of the
student's parents. The co-author also spent time as an "observer as
participant" (Glesne, 1999) in the students' high school classroom. From
these interviews and observations, she transcribed the tapes, made
careful notes, and wrote reminder memos.
In our analysis, we looked for themes and
trends within the research. We used multiple sources, implementing what
is often referred to as triangulation (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). Finally,
we made comparisons from our analysis to the professional literature on
transition.
Transition as a Vehicle
Transition is the process through which
students leave high school and become members of an adult community. We
like to consider it a "vehicle" because this process takes the student
from one place and delivers him or her to another. For the rest of the
article, we will take you on a journey in the vehicle of transition.
(Pseudonyms have been used throughout to protect the confidentiality of
the participants and programs.)
The Journey Begins:
Joshua's Story
Joshua bounds into the school with a
spring in his step and a smile for all. He chirps a cheerful "Good
morning," then begins his daily routine. Joshua is a tall, dark-haired
young man who always has a smile on his face. He is very social and
delights in making new acquaintances. He has become an icon in the halls
of Central High School. Most know Joshua, and if they do not, he will
introduce himself to them before the year is through. This social
butterfly is also a 21-year-old student with developmental disabilities
and a secondary diagnosis of severe mental retardation. Joshua's
disability has resulted in significant limitations. For example, Joshua
has limited communication skills, he is very distractible, and he
engages in self injurious behaviors when frustrated. Joshua is
experiencing his final first day of school as a high school student. He
will graduate from Central High School this year. After 5 years of high
school programming, he is finally ready to begin his 6th and final year.
He can officially be called a senior. Joshua does not realize the time,
careful planning, prayer, preparation, and compromise that have occurred
to guide his career path.
The transition process that enables this
career path choice began several years ago. This same process will guide
Joshua through the preparations and training needed for his upcoming
vocational future. It will guide him after he has graduated from high
school. The transition process is a critical career map that will keep
Joshua moving in a forward direction.
What Are High Schools
Doing to Prepare Students for Transition?
The goal in educating students with
disabilities has to be to help them become productive members of society
as adults; however, few schools have directed these students into
meaningful employment opportunities that are appropriate for their
strengths and achievements (Wehman & Revell, 1997). Quite often, an
adult vocational service provider could assist such a student in
developing his or her vocational strengths and opportunities. Before a
specific service provider can be chosen, however, the high schools have
to "do their job" in preparing students to become productive citizens.
According to Wehman & Revell (1997):
Transition for any student with a
disability involves several key components, including: (1) an
appropriate school program; (2) formalized plans involving parents and
the entire array of community agencies that are responsible for
providing services; and (3) multiple, quality options for gainful
employment and meaningful post-school education and community living.
(p. 67)
The program in place at Central High
School strives to provide an optimal education for students with
disabilities. We will show you what curriculum and experiences are in
place in order to guarantee appropriate programming.
Five years ago, Joshua came to Central
High School at the age of 15. For Joshua's first 3 years, he was
integrated into high school activities as much as possible. He joined a
music class, participated in an adapted physical education class with no
disabled peers, and enjoyed lunch in the cafeteria every day. Within his
special education classroom, Joshua was beginning to work on vocational
tasks designed to increase his time on task, promote independence at
jobs, and teach general work habits. His days were very well-rounded and
included integration activities, functional academics, and vocational
tasks. Joshua spent most of his days within the walls of the high
school.
When Joshua began his 4th of 6 years at
the high school, his programming began to change. The emphasis on
in-school integration was replaced by an emphasis on integration into
the community. He began to explore community-based vocational work
sites. These work sites were officially classified as learning
experiences, not as employment, as defined by the Fair Labor Standards
Act (Pumpian, Fisher, Certo, Engel, & Mautz, 1998). In Joshua's 6th and
final year of high school, he is in the process of completing several
jobs at community based work sites during his school week. At these
sites, Joshua is exposed to various tasks in a variety of businesses. He
performs jobs under the watchful eye of a job coach employed by the
school district. The job coach teaches work skills to Joshua and, when
necessary, assists him in completing the task. The aim of this program
is to increase Joshua's independence so that ultimately he will be able
to complete the job independently. This would obviously make him more
employable after graduation. Research has also shown that students with
developmental disabilities who had a work-study experience while in
school had a significantly higher level of vocational adjustment than
students who took regular academic programs that did not involve work
experience (Brolin, Durand, Kromer, & Muller, 1989).
The job coach oversees the tasks and also
teaches basic work habits such as punctuality and responsibility while
at work. She also continues to teach a sequence of skills and activities
that build upon one another, increasing in complexity and promoting
mastery of basic skills. Another goal is for Joshua to develop
problem-solving skills and higher-order critical thinking. This
work-based learning also helps him develop and apply social skills.
Joshua also receives functional academic
instruction in the classroom as it relates to transition. He is
instructed in money use, knowledge of personal information, telephone
usage, and survival sign recognition and application, and he is involved
in continued communication activities. Along with vocational and
academic instruction, Joshua performs daily living skills such as
cooking, cleaning, laundry, and personal care. He also receives
instruction in community awareness and access. He participates in
activities such as shopping at grocery stores or the mall and going to a
movie theater, bowling alley, skating rink, and public library. He also
learns how to use public transportation by taking the city bus to
several of these destinations.
The Individualized
Education Program (IEP) Drives Transition
In determining the previously mentioned
areas for instruction, Joshua's educational team met with Joshua to
ascertain what skills needed to be incorporated into his school day.
This team consists of Joshua, his parents, the teacher, and a school
administrator from the high school. Support staff from the intermediate
education unit are also on the team, and they include the work
experience coordinator, a consultant, the school social worker, and a
speech pathologist. Transition programs require the support and
activities provided by transition teams in order to effect meaningful
change (Blalock, 1996).
The approach that is used is an
outcomes-based one; that is, the team looks ahead to where Joshua is
going after graduation and then outlines the services and instruction
that he needs to get there. To this effect, the IEP drives Joshua's
transition to life after graduation. Through assessments and analyses of
existing programs in the community, the team members mutually determine
that upon graduation, Joshua will be served by an adult vocational
service provider in the community. This decision was made because the
team feels Joshua will benefit from the ongoing support and structure
that this type of provider can offer him. One of the highest priorities
of the team is to find a program that can allow Joshua to maintain his
high level of community-based employment. Joshua and his mother, along
with the work experience coordinator and teacher, agree to tour the
three programs that are available in the area.
Joshua's mother has been extremely happy
with the high school program and wants an adult vocational program that
provides the same kinds of training and experiences. She knows the adult
service providers are primarily vocational in nature and expects to see
as much on the tours. She is also concerned that the level of care that
Joshua receives remain high. She indicates that she doesn't want to see
him "sitting at a table, bored, or aimlessly wandering around all day
without someone keeping him on task."
Joshua's teacher wants to find a place
where a "best match" could be made for Joshua (Sitlington, Neubert,
Begun, Lombard, & Leconte, 1996). The best match for Joshua would mean
that through analysis, his strengths and weaknesses would be taken into
account and then compared against the different environments. She wants
his strengths and preferences taken into consideration and programmed
for in such a way that he can continue to become more independent. She
believes that such independence requires continuation of Joshua's
community job placement. Joshua has a real talent for working with
others in a competitive job in the community, and he has trained for a
community job throughout his last 3 years of high school. Joshua's
teacher would hate to see this training wasted. She also knows that his
level of happiness would decrease if he were to be placed within a
rehabilitation facility all day. Through assessment data, the team knows
that Joshua thrives on social interaction that can best be achieved in
the community.
Choosing the
Destination-Adult Vocational Service Providers
Joshua and his mother have just begun the
long journey that other students and their parents have already
completed. This study looked at three other students who had chosen a
destination upon graduation from high school. Each of the three chose a
different adult vocational service provider. To gain insight into their
choices and the programs, one of the coauthors conducted several
interviews at each facility and spent approximately 10 contact hours at
each location conducting observations as a participant observer (Glesne,
1999).
According to Steele, Burrows, Kiburz, and
Sitlington (1990), "The facility should never be viewed or utilized as a
training vehicle to teach work skills and behaviors" (p. 28). It seems,
however, that all three of the rehabilitation facilities visited used
this as their main goal. Steele et al. went on to say, "Usually the
opposite occurs in that individuals acquire undesirable behaviors and
develop few work skills that are applicable to community employment" (p.
28). A vocational program should be seen as a service that can help
provide competitive employment and supported employment, as well as
high-level facility-based employment. We are going to describe the three
adult service providers that the three former Central High School
students chose to attend after graduation: Connections, Pathways, and
Vocational, Inc.
Connections
Tom, the transition coordinator for
Connections, sat in a quiet office where he answered various questions
posed about the facility and the programs that are run within the
system. Connections has just increased its program space and
capabilities by adding another building that is aimed at serving a
higher functioning population. These groups of consumers typically are
individuals who live in some type of supported residential living. Along
with vocational goals, they are working on increasing their social
skills.
Tom stated, "Our goal is to try to have
high expectations for them (consumers) and get them into some type of
employment [in] the community." Currently, Connections' main service
population is adults who have been institutionalized for some time,
although the program gradually is serving more young adults entering
directly from high school. As the students graduate, Connections looks
at their needs and abilities to see what kind of vocational programming
is available for each student.
Tom explained the transition process from
high school to a Connections program. He said that they work with the
classroom teacher "if the teacher is fired up and energetic and wants to
be involved. On the other hand, sometimes it doesn't seem as if the
teacher cares one way or another" He believes that for the majority of
the students, the high schools are doing a great job in preparing them
for their facility. He did caution, however, that the schools sometimes
spend too much time on producing "letter stuffers and lettuce
shredders." Tom believes that the students are not taught how to be
flexible for changes in jobs. He would rather see basic work habits for
example, following directions, being punctual, and being
adaptable-taught to the students. Tom also believes the socialization
skills are far improved from where they were 20 years ago. As he
expressed it, "Special education has done so many wonderful things as
far as being able to fit in with a group, being able to socialize, being
able to make eye contact and communicate."
Tom was asked about the process that is
in place for transitioning a student from high school graduation to work
in a community placement. He responded that it is a "commonsense" type
of placement. Tom noted that sometimes the schools are able to help
determine appropriate placements. If Connections is unable to obtain
much information on a student, the staff will place the client at a
workstation and, after initial placement, move him or her around as his
or her abilities allow. Connections will try jobs that require moving
around the building, and if the client succeeds at these placements,
eventually he or she will be placed on mobile work crews. If the
individual is successful at this level, he/she will be recommended for
competitive employment in a supported situation
Finally, when asked what would make the
transition process easier, Tom replied:
Keep them (students) in school so you can
give them a variety of vocational experiences. The funding is there at
the high school-keep them there as long as you can. Also teach them to
be flexible and not just focus on a specific job and saying this is what
they do. More than anything, teach people that life is change. Change is
the hardest thing to learn of all. The problem is if you teach them to
be an envelope stuffer and then they come here and we have to teach them
about change. We have less qualifications and less money than the
schools do. That isn't quite fair.
To assist in illustrating our impression
of the Connections program, in the following section we will share our
observations of Joe, a former student who is currently employed by
Connections. For each succeeding program we discuss, we will include
similar observational data on the former Central High School student
employed through that program.
Joe's Story
Joe is a 19-year-old individual with
autism who has been at Connections for 1 month. He has been diagnosed
with a moderate mental disability. From the perspective of educators and
other professionals, Joe's strengths are often diminished by his need to
seek adverse attention from adults he deems to be "in charge." In other
words, he has cleverly discerned that it is easier to gain attention by
acting in a provocative manner to persons in positions of authority. In
this regard, he is no different from many other adolescents or young
adults; predictably enough, his antics create obstacles to his
vocational success and future opportunities.
Within the large, yet quiet, room that is
part of Connections, all of the consumers seemed actively engaged in
various activities. Joe was sitting at a table with five other consumers
and one supervisor. They were engaged in a social skills class that
centered on dealing with one's own and others' emotions. They were
looking in magazines for people who were smiling. This activity is
similar to social skills classes in which Joe would have participated
and that he would have enjoyed while in high school.
After his social skills instruction,
where he actively participated with the other consumers, Joe
transitioned to the break area, where he had a snack. Joe looked like an
old pro as he moved to this area and enjoyed his treat. After his snack,
he had 45 minutes to complete a task, which consisted of wiping off the
table, sweeping the floor, mopping the floor, and setting the table for
lunch. This daily task was one of his assigned duties. All of these jobs
would be consistent with the programming he had at Central High.
Tom indicated that one of the goals of
the program is to teach the consumers skills that would be applied when
they move into a group home or apartment. Joe's supervisor indicated
that he did a good job of completing his service job, but he did need
prompts to stay on task and not wander into other areas. These skills
are also similar to programming that Joe received in high school.
Connections, therefore, was still teaching transition skills for the
next step in Joe's life.
The building housing Connections was an
open area that allowed viewing of other activities that were occurring
simultaneously. In one corner, two consumers and a supervisor were
making garbage bags that were to be used in residential facilities where
some of the consumers lived. Next to the kitchen area, where the service
jobs were occurring, five consumers and a supervisor were putting
coupons into picture envelopes for a film-processing company. In another
corner, there was a break area where two consumers were playing a game
of cards. Other areas in the room included a nurse's office, the social
skills table, and an exercise area that contained a treadmill and an
exercise bike.
One of the supervisors indicated that the
consumers rotated throughout the day to the different areas. Each person
had an individualized schedule. Connections also had three work crews
that were out on job sites. The individuals who go on these sites rotate
in and out. Joe had not yet gone into the community. The supervisor
anticipated that he would be placed on a work crew when he was able to
stay on-task for longer periods of time.
One of the most impressive observations
made while at Connections was that the consumers were always engaged in
an activity. They seemed to be progressing through specified objectives
and plans. Tom shared Joe's Individualized Program Plan (IPP). This
document was similar to the school's IEP in that Joe's schedule was
specifically designed to be consistent with the goals in his IPP.
Another similarity included aspects of his vocational training, such as
increasing his time on task.
Another impressive observation about
Connections was the ratio of consumers to staff members. Seven staff
members were assigned to 17 consumers. Each consumer was receiving the
personal attention that he or she needed.
In summary, it appeared that this highly
organized program implemented many of the transition activities and
processes of the Central High School program. Moreover, we were
favorably impressed by the varied and well-planned activities.
From here, we move to a description of
the Pathways program. Our observations of Jill, the former Central High
student enrolled in Pathways, will serve to depict the vocational and
transition services offered through this program. As will become clear
to the reader, several aspects of Pathways services were less than
adequate from our perspective.
Pathways
As one enters the automatic door at the
Pathways, a large sign directs visitors to the office. Once in the
office, visitors sign in, listing name, purpose of visit, and contacts
to see while in the building. Visitors are then given a bright orange
name badge that reads "Visitor." Clearly this is not a place for casual
observations.
Theresa, the transition coordinator for
the facility, immediately apologized. Because this was her first year as
a transition coordinator, she was afraid that she would not be able to
answer all of the questions posed to her. Theresa began by stating that
Pathways was a facility that concentrated on different skills for the
consumers. A vocational facility, Pathways' job offerings included work
involving outside contracts from businesses that are brought back to the
facility for the consumers. This was the only source for consumer work
within the facility. Pathways also had a few consumers involved in
supported employment and some who were on regular work crews.
Pathways was organized into different
sections that were labeled, and actually called, the "Red Room," the
"Blue Room," and so forth. Consumers were grouped according to their
functioning levels and disability labels and then placed in these
various rooms. When Theresa was asked what assessments were conducted in
order to accurately place students in these various groups, she
indicated that ideally she likes to see the students in the high school
classroom before they graduate in order to get an idea of their skill
levels and capabilities. She would prefer to make the initial visit
during the student's junior year of high school.
Theresa also attends the student's senior
year IEP conference where the transition to Pathways can be planned. In
the past, the student has attended the facility for half days before the
actual graduation and move occurs. Before a consumer officially attends
the facility, a screening meeting occurs with staff from Pathways, the
consumer, his or her parents, the case manager, and the classroom
teacher. At this meeting, Theresa stated, the student's "capabilities,
skills, behaviors, . . . aggressions" are discussed. It is then decided
which section the student is best suited to attend.
Once the student is placed into a
section, there is very little movement to other sections. Theresa could
not recall any consumers who had been placed in another section when
they became proficient at the skills in which they were currently
engaged. She was also not aware of the placement issue ever being
revisited after a set time period-or annually, as the school IEP had
been.
Each section was assigned contractual
work that was brought into the facility. These contracts were
specifically assigned to a certain section. If one section's members ran
out of work, they did not borrow work from somewhere else. The sections
often ran out of work, and the consumers sat idle, not engaged in
activities. The section labeled as the "highest functioning"-the "Purple
Room"-always had the most varied and complex work, and its members were
usually kept busy with contracts to finish. Most of these individuals
worked independently and needed little prompting. These consumers
appeared to be excellent candidates for com-munity job placement or
competitive employment instead of completing contracts within the
facility, and such a move would also leave more work for individuals
with more significant disabilities.
As noted previously, some sections did
not have work all of the time, and many of the consumers sat idly or
walked around the room. In three of the sections, Red, Green, and
Yellow, the focus was not on vocational tasks. Theresa described these
sections as more "recreational in nature." These consumers seemed to be
the "lower functioning" individuals. One section that was of particular
interest, the Blue Room, was set aside for individuals with
developmental disabilities. Jill, a member of this section, graduated
from Central High last year and had just completed her first year at
Pathways.
Jill's Story
As one approaches the Blue Room, one
notices an enclosed room with construction paper over all of the
windows. A "Please Knock" sign hangs on the door. Jill is 22 years old,
is nonverbal, and has severe disabilities. She communicates by using
some signs that are strictly her own. While in high school, she worked
independently at familiar vocational tasks, such as shredding papers,
sorting colors, and stuffing envelopes. She had also worked two times a
week at a used clothing shop in a no paid, community-based experience
involving a job coach and one other student. At this store, she hung
shirts on hangers. She was also in charge of operating the washer and
dryer.
In high school, elements of structured
teaching were in place in the classroom. Jill used a visual schedule to
transition through her day. She completed tasks in a top-to-bottom, left
to-right fashion. Jill could stay on task at independent jobs for up to
30 minutes without requiring a break. The high school provided her with
weekly community mobility trips and integration into physical education
classes; she also ate lunch every day in the cafeteria with the rest of
the student body. Jill was regarded as a good worker, and the employer
at the clothing store enjoyed having her there each week.
In the Blue Room at Pathways, Jill was
sitting at a table by herself. The only activity in which she was
engaged was repetitively taking her shoes on and off. Along the
perimeter of the room were cubicles composed of U-shaped room dividers
and a sheet pulled across the opening. Each consumer in the Blue Room
had a cubicle. In addition, a cubicle at the end of the row was used
specifically for sensory experiences. This cubicle was darkened and
contained various lights and vibrator devices.
Although the Blue Room had a visual
schedule system for each of its consumers to use, these were not
utilized during the numerous observations made at the facility. There
were seven consumers and an adult who was the "sub" in the room. This
sub sat behind her desk marking on white paper bags a task that appeared
to be part of a contract for that section. Jill was sitting at the table
in the middle of the room with a bucket of various toys and a
preschool-level wooden farm yard puzzle. She was engaged in a
self-stimulation activity, twirling puzzle pieces between her fingers.
She was also continually taking her shoes and socks on and off at a rate
of approximately three times per minute. The other consumers in the room
were sitting around tables, wandering around the room, sleeping, or
pushing a chair around the room; one consumer was drinking ice water. No
one was working on this particular morning, and most individuals did not
even have a recreational item in front of them. When one of the
consumers would wander up to the sub, she would tell them, "You need to
sit down." It appeared the consumers were quite bored. This nonactivity
continued throughout the observation period.
As one of the co-authors was conducting
the observations, another adult entered the room. She was the area
supervisor who originally transitioned Jill to the facility and helped
to decide that the Blue Room was the appropriate placement. She began
asking questions of the co-author (Jill's former teacher) about Jill.
These questions were asked in front of Jill, discussing her as if she
were not in the room. The questions ranged from basic brainstorming
questions ("How can we keep her shoes on?") to whether Jill had ever
been taken for a walk while in high school. Apparently during the whole
year in which Jill had been at this facility, they had never taken her
out of the Blue Room.
Consumers in the Blue Room used a
bathroom housed within their room; the group ate lunch in this same
room, although Pathways did have a cafeteria. When asked why they ate in
the room, Kay, the supervisor, told me, "Consumers like this cannot
handle the unstructured nature of the cafeteria." The consumers also
completed all of their vocational and recreational activities within the
walls of this room. Once the consumers entered in the morning, they
literally did not see outside their room until they went home at night.
This area had no windows to the outside, and as noted earlier, the only
windows to the inside were covered with construction paper.
By all accounts, the Blue Room was
supposedly a wonderful, cutting-edge program. A nearby well-known
university had trained the staff in this room in structured teaching
methods. By word of mouth, this program was highly recommended as "the
place to go" for persons with developmental disabilities. Once you were
allowed in the private room, however, it became evident that the quality
of the program was in name only.
It appeared that Jill had regressed
immensely since her graduation from high school 1 year ago. At that
time, she had several work skills, all of which were highlighted during
her transition. Were these forgotten by the Pathways staff or were they
simply ignored? If the staff at Pathways truly did not know the extent
of Jill's abilities, why wasn't an assessment of her skills completed?
It seems as if the school has failed Jill. Obviously, the transition was
not as complete as the IEP team would have hoped, because much of the
information regarding her previous knowledge and milestones did not seem
to have been disseminated to the staff at Pathways. This example made us
realize that another major role of the transition team has to be
advocating for the student. Some type of follow-through should also be
completed to make sure we are best meeting the needs of the student.
In summary, there was a lack of
continuity with the high school program, community placement of
individuals with disabilities was not a priority, and there was a
definite lack of meaningful work. In addition, there was no evidence of
an assessment process for the consumers. From our perspective, Pathways
provided a glorified adult daycare service under the pretense of a
vocational program.
We will now describe the third adult
vocational service provider that is an employment option for
Joshua-Vocational, Inc. A former Central High student, Chad, is an
employee of Vocational, Inc. Our observations will serve to depict the
vocational and transition services offered in this program.
Vocational, Inc.
Vocational, Inc., is a well-known adult
vocational service provider with a number of separate sites. The company
has its own retail stores, can recycling operation, contract area, and
donation sorting area. All of these constitute employment opportunities
for consumers. In addition, Vocational, Inc., employs persons with and
without disabilities. Some of the individuals who do not have
disabilities are hired as job coaches within the facility; others are
hired to complete a certain job, as they would be hired to do in any
other place of employment.
Vocational, Inc., offers a range of
in-house work as well as supported employment, competitive employment,
workplace evaluations, and case management services. The transition
coordinator, Christine, outlined the services that Vocational, Inc.,
provides while detailing how each service was accessed.
The transition process begins with a
referral from the Division of Vocational Rehabilitation. Vocational
Rehabilitation serves as a time-limited funding source for most of the
consumers who utilize the services. After the time-limited funding
expires, the consumer's program is funded by the county. Once referred,
the consumer goes through a multi week work evaluation program composed
of multiple assessments that measure the consumer's strengths and
weaknesses across several environments. Christine described it as, "kind
of like a work crew that they would do at school. We would try the
stores, housecleaning, janitorial, contracts, containers, the can
line-all the different things we would do here."
The assessments look at basic work
skills, including items such as on-task behavior and punctuality, as
well as other areas needed for employment, such as appearance and
manners. Vocational, Inc., uses a checklist that focuses on
approximately 10 different behaviors. Based on this checklist, the
transition coordinator writes recommendations for the consumer. If the
individual has not had much experience, the next step the coordinator
would recommend would be a work adjustment training period.
Work adjustment training is another multi
week period where the consumer is working at the facility and polishing
his or her work readiness skills. At this time, job coaches might be
working with the consumer to train the individual in some specific areas
where he or she needs remediation. This is also a good time for the
consumer and Vocational, Inc., to begin the process leading to supported
employment in the community for the individual. If the consumer is ready
for out-of-facility employment, Vocational, Inc., would assist him or
her in creating a resume and selecting a job that is a good match. The
criteria for matching a consumer to a job are the consumer's interests
and formally assessed skill levels. Initially, all consumers who go out
into the community are supported by a job coach. This support continues
as long as the consumer has a need for it.
After the work adjustment period is
completed, Vocational, Inc., provides a recommendation for the client. A
consumer plan, similar to the IEP that the education system utilizes, is
devised. This plan details vocational goals for the consumer for the
following year and drives the vocational program for him or her. If the
consumer is not ready for community placement or supported employment,
he or she will be assigned a job within Vocational, Inc. 's, facilities.
Each consumer's progress is closely monitored, and his or her goals are
updated on a regular basis. The goal of the program is to assist the
consumer in obtaining community employment as soon as he or she is
ready. Clearly, Vocational, Inc., wants the consumers to find meaningful
employment that matches their interests and skill levels.
I asked Christine how well she felt the
high school programs were preparing the students who were coming to
work. She replied, "I think a lot of students come in with office/
clerical skills and have some basic skills in that area. It's not always
the best because there aren't always jobs out there in that. Actually,
there are very few jobs in that field." She added that one of the areas
for which she would like high schools to prepare the students would be
service-oriented types of jobs, particularly positions involving retail
store skills. The retail area was where she felt more jobs were
available.
When asked what she believed would
improve the transition from high school to their facility, Christine
stated that "communicating with the parents" was a big area that
sometimes did not get enough attention. She wanted to see the high
schools introduce the parents to Vocational Rehabilitation, Vocational,
Inc., and other vocational service providers, as well as all of the
available residential options. In her opinion, this process needed to
begin earlier than the student's junior or senior year because by that
time, "The parents get so much information and are so overloaded." We
believe she made a good point.
Christine also believed that students
would greatly benefit from preparation regarding employers' expectations
in terms of work habits. For instance, they should learn the importance
of taking responsibility for calling in if they were unable to be at
work. She believed that these major work habits and ethics were missing
from the students' skills. She felt that too often, students with
disabilities are excessively sheltered and are not compelled to take
responsibility for their own actions. Responsibility is key to obtaining
and maintaining employment.
Road Advisory Report
Throughout the previous sections, the
reader has had the opportunity to see an in-depth view of three
different adult vocational service providers and the stories of three
consumers. All three of these consumers had graduated from the same
program at the same high school. Given that each student had the same
education, one might think their transitions and employment might
resemble one another. This was not the case, however.
Chad's Story
As one enters the large warehouse room,
one quickly gets the impression that everyone is focused on the business
at hand. Each person is engaged in some task. Twelve consumers are
sitting at various stations, diligently peeling tape off of plastic bags
or using a razor blade to cut labels off the bags. A radio plays softly
in the background; the mood is set for a very comfortable work
environment. This scenario is similar to what may be seen at some of the
various factories around the area. One supervisor and one trainer wander
among the consumers, monitoring the quality and pace of their work. In
the middle of this area, Chad is working steadily. His smile and facial
expression show pleasant concentration.
This was Chad's third year at Vocational,
Inc. At Central High, he was always regarded as a good worker. He had
always worked well independently, but occasionally he had some problems
with social skills and working with others. Chad split his days between
this contract area and a custodial area. In the custodial area, he
worked with Rusty, the janitor, and cleaned parts of the facility. The
supervisor said that Chad was working very well and his productivity was
high. In addition, he was talking to others much more than in the past.
At 10:00 A.M., Chad and all of the
other consumers got up and went into the break room. Chad sat quietly
and drank a soda during his 15-minute break. He seemed at ease with the
other consumers. The room looked like any other break room: There were
vending machines in the corner and a newspaper and magazines to read.
Time passed quickly, and the consumers filed out of the room and punched
the time clock in order to begin working again. Chad followed suit and
was quickly back on task with his plastic bags.
After lunch, Chad began his custodial
duties for the day. Rusty said that in the afternoon, Chad cleaned the
cafeteria, wiped off tables, filled napkin holders, cleaned bathrooms,
and emptied garbage. In the beginning of Chad's training, they gave him
a flip chart to show how to complete each task, but he did not need this
tool anymore. Rusty noted, however, that it was very hard for Chad to
change routines.
After graduation, it took some time for
Chad to adjust to his new environment. The transition was difficult,
requiring a lot of one-on-one sessions to calm Chad and teach him to
complete different jobs. Rusty wanted Chad to work at a community job
site, such as a hotel. Vocational, Inc., was ready to make this
placement for Chad; however, Chad's parents were apprehensive regarding
such a placement, because they feared going through yet another
transition.
Vocational, Inc., was run like a
business. It was very efficient, with a clear chain of command. The
supervisor made the comment that they never ran out of work; therefore,
all consumers could be steadily employed without "down time." Chad was
still smiling as he completed his work. Although the transition had been
difficult for Chad, it appeared that a very favorable match had been
made. He was engaged in meaningful work and, above all, was happy.
What Went Well
There were several positive aspects of
the transition process between the high school and the adult vocational
service providers. One of the most positive things was the choices that
the students with disabilities had. Throughout this article, we
described three adult service providers that worked to meet the
employment needs of adults with disabilities. In many locales, this
variety of choice would not be available. All three providers served an
important role in the community, as they were filling a desperate need.
Each of the programs employed a
transition specialist whose job was to help adolescents and young adults
with disabilities, their families, and the school staff sort through all
of the necessary procedures and make good employment matches. This
specialist was a vital link in the process. He or she disseminates
program information and helps educate persons with disabilities, their
families, and others about the upcoming changes that will be made in the
students' lives. This was evident in the specialists' participation in
Agency Nights, which described their services; it was also evident in
the specialists' participation in the local education agencies'
transition meetings. These individuals were willing to talk about their
respective programs and give tours upon request.
High schools would benefit from a strong
relationship with the transition specialists. Working relationships
between the schools and adult service agencies are at the heart of
effective transition planning (Wehman, 2001). To ensure a successful
transition, the specialists and the high school teachers need to work
together (Steele et al., 1990). Although each of the transition
specialists encouraged such a relationship, it was seen only on a
limited basis in this study.
Another positive aspect of one of the
vocational facilities Vocational, Inc.-was the use of assessment when
matching the consumer to prospective jobs. These assessments took th
form of behavior observations, situational assessments, an analysis of
background information. The assessment data wet used in determining what
jobs consumers could do well, fc which jobs they needed assistance and
training, what woi habits needed further development, what their
interests wet and what the next placement should be.
This use of assessment data has been
recommended experts in the field of transition (Sitlington, Neubert, & I
conte, 1997; Thurlow & Elliott, 1998). It is also in compliance with the
law (Baer, 2001; McDonnell, Mathot-Buckner, & Ferguson, 1996). The 1997
amendments to IDEA require that transition services and planning be
based on the student's needs, preferences, and interests. Although not
bound by this amendment, Vocational, Incas, use of assessment in
transition is a perfect example of best practice.
What Needs Improvement
Although the transition process from high
school to the adult vocational service providers had many positive
aspects, there still is room for improvement. Based on current research
and our observations and interviews, we chose four areas in which
improvement would make the transition process stronger. Those areas are
as follows:
1. More education for high school
teachers (regarding the transition process) and for the staff of the
adult vocational service providers (regarding characteristics of
individual disability areas);
2. inclusion of assessment in the
transition process;
3. increased communication among the
individual, his or her family, the school, and the adult provider; and
4. aligned programming between the school
and the adult provider.
Increased Education. As the turnover in
special education teachers has increased, it has become apparent that
all too often new teachers are assuming roles in different positions.
Upon assuming these roles, the teachers find themselves in classrooms
where they are unfamiliar with all the procedures. Teachers in high
school classrooms where there are students with disabilities must
acquaint themselves with the transition process and transition planning
for their students (McDonnell, Wilcox, & Hardman, 1991; Sitlington,
Clark, & Kolstoe, 2000).
Transition planning serves several
important functions:
· introduces the family to the adult
service system;
· determines support required by the
student to live, work, and recreate in the community as an adult;
· identifies adult service system gaps
and inadequacies, enabling transition team members to advocate for more
appropriate services;
· provides information to adult service
providers about individual needs so that these providers will not assume
all people with disabilities have identical needs when planning services
and implementing programs; and
· provides information critical to
determining appropriate IEP goals. Through the IEP, parents
and educators can target which skills
need development in order to ensure a smooth transition (Indiana
Resource Center for Autism, 1996).
According to this list, the teacher needs
to know about available adult service providers and what services each
provider offers. He or she needs to know the contact persons or
transition specialists at each agency and must also be able to relay
this information to parents and students. The teacher must develop a
timeline for the transition process and identify what steps need to be
followed in order to ensure success.
In many cases, a work experience
coordinator employed by either the school district or the intermediate
unit can be a wonderful resource regarding available services, whom to
contact, and when to contact them. Because these coordinators often are
extremely busy with large caseloads, it is still in the teacher's (and
ultimately the student's) best interest for the teacher to fully
acquaint him- or herself with this information. In order for this to
happen, the teacher must make an effort to tour the provider's facility,
talk with the staff, and become familiar with the provider.
On the other hand, the staff of the adult
service providers need to be better educated, in particular regarding
the individual student. Frequently when a student has been transitioned
into the program, the provider has tried to assimilate him or her into
its routines without looking at the individual's background. Because
these young people are in formalized programming for many years, the
various agencies should look into their backgrounds and consult with
them, their families, and the teachers to learn what has and has not
been successful for a particular individual. This is not the time to
"reinvent the wheel." Assessment data collected throughout the
transition process should be used.
Such assessment data include analysis of
background information (Sitlington et al., 1996). At Pathways, Jill's
background information was grossly ignored and simply not wanted.
Pathways' staff wanted to get to know Jill "on their own." This resulted
in a severe regression in skills from where Jill had been in her high
school programming. An analysis of her background information could have
prevented this regression.
Staff members of the adult service
providers should make an effort to be better educated about the
different disability characteristics of their consumers. Although
Vocational, Inc., and Connections ran non categorical programs where the
consumers were not separated by disabilities, the staff members should
still be aware of specific needs that must be met due to the particular
individual's disabilities. Similarly, at Pathways, which ran categorical
programs, staff members should be continually trained in the disability
areas in order to best work with the consumers. Although staff at
Pathways had extensive preliminary training, there had been no further
training. In addition, it appeared that Pathways' staff did not
recognize that the provider cannot offer a "cookie cutter" program where
the same strategies and accommodations are applied to all of their
consumers.
Specifically, individuals with autism may
need specialized programming in vocational areas and transition that
addresses communication needs, comprehension deficits, socialization
deficiencies, responses to sensory stimulation, and ability to handle
change (Simpson & Zionts, 2000; Smith, Belcher, & Juhrs, 1995). Staff of
adult providers would enhance the transition process by increasing their
knowledge of specific disabilities. This knowledge would help them to
develop programs that meet the needs of the consumers.
Assessment in
Transition
"As individuals with disabilities make
the transition from school to adult life, the process of assessment is
critical in all areas and stages of planning. Assessment in career
development, vocational decision making, and transition planning is an
essential process that is often overlooked, ignored, or misunderstood"
(Sitlington et al., 1997, p. 69). While the student is in high school,
various assessments need to occur in order to best plan for his or her
future (Flexer & Luft, 2001; Flexer, Simmons, Luft, & Baer, 2001).
Transition assessment focuses on the student's current and future roles
as a worker, lifelong learner, family member, community citizen, and
participant in social and interpersonal networks (Sitlington et al.,
1996). Assessment must occur in the high school, and decisions about the
student's future should be based on the resulting data. Assessment can
assist in determining a student's interests, strengths, areas for
improvement, future placements, and areas for future programming (Flexer
& Luft, 2001; Sitlington et al., 2000).
Assessment can be conducted by different
methods, including analysis of background information, interviews,
psychometric tests, work samples, curriculum-based assessment,
behavioral observations, and situational assessments (Sitlington et al.,
2000). Once the individual has been assessed, the environment should
also be assessed. The environmental assessment should include an
analysis of the living environment, a job analysis, a program analysis,
and an analysis of resources in the target environment. The next step is
to compare the individual and environmental data to see if there is a
"match." Once a match is determined, the transition process can continue
with the appropriate vocational service provider (Sitlington et al.,
1996).
This method of assessment should also be
conducted by the adult vocational service provider (Flexer & Luft,
2001). Vocational, Inc., has had great success by completing work
evaluations and work adjustments to determine how it can best serve the
consumer. Assessment would also be beneficial at Connections and
Pathways. Theresa at Pathways noted that such ongoing assessment did not
occur in that particular program. Once a consumer was placed into one of
the categorical rooms, there was no established method for movement into
other sections. In addition, different jobs and work assignments were
based on the category of the room and not on the individual abilities of
the consumer. Similarly, only certain categories of consumers were
allowed to complete supported employment in the community, and this
community placement was determined by the room category on the
consumer’s characteristics.
Increased Communication
When asked what would make the transition
process smoother, Christine of Vocational, Inc., easily cited
communication as the most essential component of the process. This
communication needs to occur among the student, his or her family, the
school, and the future vocational facility. Unfortunately, is not
commencing soon enough or occurring consistently enough in many
transitions (Wehman, 2001).
According to the 1997 amendments to IDEA,
transition planning needs to begin by the time the person is 14. Its
purpose should be to develop a course of study. Including the student
and the family this early in the process offers them time to adjust to
the idea of transition and to obtain enough education and information
about future changes to make informed decisions (Neubert, 2000).
Beginning discussions of future vocational placements early and making
the student and his or her family the main focus of these discussions
lays the groundwork for future meetings on transition.
During the student's junior year, it is
appropriate to bring in staff members from the adult vocational service
provider. This linkage should be created only after the student and
family have had time to visit a number of programs and to select and
thoroughly examine the program that they believe to be the best match
for them. Bringing in the transition specialist at this time in the
student's high school career allows enough time for him or her to get to
know the student and for the student to feel comfortable about the
upcoming transition. It also helps to put parents at ease, especially if
they are apprehensive about their son or daughter leaving a formalized
educational setting of which they have been a part for many years.
Aligned Programming.
Wehman and Revell (1997) cautioned that
secondary programs are not providing instruction in ways that will be
functional for students with disabilities in terms of gaining employment
or making successful transitions into adulthood. These secondary
programs should offer several key components to help students secure
meaningful employment in the future. According to Wehman and Revell
(1997),
First, school programming needs to be
revamped to include community-based job training. Second, parents and
professionals must develop formal, written plans for transition. Third,
schools and community agencies will have to work with businesses to
develop a variety of meaningful employment options for citizens with
disabilities. (p. 67)
If these three components are in place, a
successful transition into meaningful employment is possible (McDonnell
et al., 1996; Wehman, 2001). In particular, supported employment needs
to be a top priority for increased quality of life. The definition of
supported employment in the Rehabilitation Act Amendments of 1992 has
three features:
1. It involves competitive work in
integrated work settings for individuals with the most significant
disabilities.
2. It targets individuals for whom
competitive employment has not traditionally occurred or has been
interrupted or intermittent because of significant disability.
3. It makes available ongoing support
services at and/or away from the worksite as needed for the supported
employee to successfully maintain employment.
Noted Wehman and Revell (1997),
Successful implementation of supported
employment requires attention to a number of factors starting with a
clear focus on employment in community integrated settings ... it is not
readiness training in classrooms or work centers intended to develop
generalized skills for use in a job sometime in the future. (p. 68)
Throughout this study, there have been
some deviations from what experts say should be the best practices. For
all of the individuals in this study, high school careers and curricula
have looked similar. Chad, Joe, Jill, and Joshua all participated in an
outcomes-based program where a "team" of individuals that included the
student, his or her family, the classroom teacher, various support staff
from the intermediate service unit, and community providers met to
discuss where the student was headed after graduation and what skills he
or she needed in order to get there.
All four students' high school programs
included community-based work experiences. These experiences were in
place for their career development and typically provided the following:
career awareness, career exploration, and career preparation. During the
transition years of the students' high school program (ages 18 to 21),
more time was focused on career preparation. These students were
assigned work experiences in the community, where they developed work
habits and responsibilities as well as specific job skills.
By the time the students graduated, they
had spent a considerable amount of time working in the community. The
next logical step would be to continue this community work under the
supervision of the adult vocational service provider to which the
student was in the process of transitioning. By better aligning adult
vocational services and the student's curriculum during high school,
less regression among the students will occur. The students will have a
greater chance for supported employment and, ultimately, a better
quality of life. This means striving to place individuals in the
community in supported employment roles (i.e., enclaves, work crews)
instead of having them complete facility-based contract work. These
people can work in the community and need to be given this opportunity.
Ideally, the school and the adult service providers will work closely
together during the student's senior year to identify a specific
placement for the student as he or she graduates (Steele et al., 1990).
Arriving at a
Destination
Although it is clear that a "perfect map"
for transition does not always exist, it must be the responsibility of
high school teachers to strive for a well-planned move into an adult
career for each of their students. This transition process involves the
teamwork of many individuals, including the student and his or her
family, the teacher, the local education agency support team, and
members from various adult service agencies (Iowa Department of
Education, 1999; Sitlington et al., 2000; Wehman, 2001).
Joshua's transition involved just such a
team of individuals. Joshua and his mother shared their preferences and
visions of what life after high school would look like for him. They
toured Pathways, Vocational, Inc., and Connections. Throughout his
senior year, transition team meetings were held to ensure that the team
was still on the "right highway" for Joshua. The team reevaluated his
goals and discussed consistency of programming between the school and
the adult service provider. Joshua and his mother ultimately selected
Connections as his place of employment after graduation.
Several factors made Connections a
desirable destination for Joshua and his family. The first was the
assurance that supported employment in the community would be a
possibility for Joshua. His mother wanted to continue the successes he
had in high school when working in the community. Another factor Joshua
and his mother valued was the consistency between the high school and
the adult service provider. Joshua also liked the other consumers at
Connections. It appeared that he will meet many friends while employed
there. Overall, Connections was a good match for Joshua and his family.
After Connections was selected, the IEP
team met with the provider's representatives. Connections' staff members
spent several meetings getting to know Joshua. Connections'
representatives were invited to-and attended-Joshua's senior IEP
meeting. They assisted the team in developing goals for Joshua that
would be consistent with their programming. They also assisted the team
in devising a transition plan for Joshua. This plan details when Joshua
will begin work at Connections. He will begin working half-days in their
program before he graduates from high school. This learning time will
help ease Joshua into his new routine. His transition plan also includes
transportation details and how the needed transportation skills will be
taught, as Joshua will have to use a different transportation system to
get to and from work. By establishing this link with Connections, the
school staff was able to move Joshua gently from school to work with the
least possible disturbance in his life and without any lapses in
services. Joshua seemed happy with the upcoming move, and his mother was
confident and at ease during a very dif-ficult time. She undoubtedly was
experiencing the same feelings that other mothers of high school seniors
feel as they move into the next step of their lives. Through this
vehicle known as transition, Joshua has arrived at the next destination
in his life.
Conclusion
Throughout this study, we examined in
detail the vocational lives of four individuals who graduated from the
same high school program. Each individual chose a different career path
at an adult service provider in the area. We examined each facility and
followed up with each student to see what was successful for him or her
as well as what needed improvement. We also examined the professional
literature on these topics and wove this knowledge into this article.
Obtaining this information allowed us to learn what high schools can do
to assist in this type of transition.
We identified various successful aspects
of each adult provider, including the employment of knowledgeable
transition specialists, the variety of choices students and their
families had in this geographic area, and the use of assessment data in
one of the agencies.
We also noted four areas for improvement,
based on literature from professionals in the field of transition and on
our own observations. The areas were increased education of high school
teachers and staff of the adult vocational service providers; the use of
assessment data throughout transition; increased communication among the
student and his or her family, the school, and the future adult
vocational service provider; and aligned programming between the high
school and the students' future environments.
This study also allowed the reader to
take an in-depth look at one aspect of the transition to adult life for
a high school senior. We detailed the steps that the transition team
took to help make a good match for this student to ensure his continued
happiness and satisfaction in his life as a young adult. Transition, if
not under repair, is the vehicle that transports individuals from one
stage of their lives to the other. Joshua and his family enjoyed their
trip.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
MICHELLE L. NEUHRING, MEd, is a
special education teacher for the Cedar Rapids, Iowa, public schools.
Her interests focus on transition to adult life for students with autism
and other severe disabilities. PATRICIA L. SITLINGTON, PhD, is a
professor at the University of Northern Iowa. Her current interests
include transition to all aspects of adult life, assessment, and
interagency collaboration. Address: Patricia L. Sitlington, Department
of Special Education, University of Northern Iowa, Cedar Falls, IA
50614-0601.
AUTHORS' NOTE
The authors wish to acknowledge Dr.
Deborah J. Gallagher for her editorial input and substantive commentary
on an earlier version of this article.
REFERENCES
Baer, R. (2001). Transition planning. In
R. W. Flexer, T. J. Simmons, P. Luft, & R. M. Baer, Transition planning
for secondary students with disabilities (pp. 333-363). Upper Saddle
River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Berg, B. (1995). Qualitative research
methods for the social sciences. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Blalock, G. (1996). Community transition
teams as the foundation for transition services for youth with learning
disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 29, 148-159.
Bogden, R., & Biklen, S. (1992).
Qualitative research for education (2nd ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Brolin, D., Durand, R., Kromer, K., &
Muller, P. (1989). Post-school adjustment of educable retarded students.
Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 24, 144-148.
Eisner, R., & Peshkin, A. (Eds.). (1990).
Qualitative inquiry in education: The continuing debate. New York:
Teachers College Press.
Flexer, R. W., & Luft, P. (2001).
Transition assessment and post school outcomes. In R. W. Flexer, T. J.
Simmons, P. Luft, & R. M. Baer, Transition planning for secondary
students with disabilities (pp. 197-226). Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice Hall.
Flexer, R. W., Simmons, T. J., Luft, P.,
& Baer, R. M. (2001). Transition planning for secondary students with
disabilities. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Glesne, C. (1999). Becoming qualitative
researchers: An introduction (2nd ed.). White Plains, NY: Longman.
Guba, E. (Ed.). (1990). The paradigm
dialog. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Individuals with Disabilities Education
Act of 1990, 20 U.S.C. § 1401.
Individuals with Disabilities Education
Act Amendments of 1997, 20 U.S.C. § 1400.
Indiana Resource Center for Autism.
(1996). Reporter, 2(1), 1-4.
Iowa Department of Education. (September,
1999). Indicators for transition improvement process. Des Moines:
Author.
Lincoln, Y., & Guba, E. (1985).
Naturalistic inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
McDonnell, J., Mathot-Buckner, C., &
Ferguson, B. (1996). Transition programs for students with
moderate/severe disabilities. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
McDonnell, J., Wilcox, B., & Hardman, M.
L. (1991). Secondary programs for students with developmental
disabilities. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Neubert, D. A. (2000). Transition
education and service guidelines. In P. L. Sitlington, G. M. Clark, & O.
P. Kolstoe, Transition education and services for adolescents with
disabilities (pp. 39-69). Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Pumpian, I., Fisher, D., Certo, N.,
Engel, T., & Mautz, D. (1998). To pay or not to pay: Differentiating
employment and training relationships through regulation and litigation.
Career Development for Exceptional Individuals, 21, 187-202.
Simpson, R. L., & Zionts, P. (2000).
Autism: Information and resources for professionals and parents. Austin:
PRO-ED.
Sitlington, P. L., Clark, G. M., &
Kolstoe, O. P. (2000). Transition education and services for adolescents
with disabilities. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Sitlington, P. L., Neubert, D. A., Begun,
W., Lombard, R. C., & Leconte, P. J. (1996). Assess for success:
Handbook on transition assessment. Reston, VA: The Council for
Exceptional Children.
Sitlington, P. L., Neubert, D. A., &
Leconte, P. J. (1997). Transition assessment: The position of the
Division on Career Development and Transition. Career Development for
Exceptional Individuals, 20(1), 69-79.
Smith, M. D., Belcher, R. G., & Juhrs, P.
D. (1995). A guide to successful employment for individuals with autism.
Baltimore: Brookes.
Steele, P., Burrows, R., Kiburz, P., &
Sitlington, P. (1990). An interagency venture: Transitioning for people
with moderate and severe disabilities. Des Moines: Iowa Dept. of
Education, Bureau of Special Education.
Thurlow, M., & Elliott, J. (1998).
Student assessment and evaluation. In F. R. Rusch & J. G. Chadsey
(Eds.), Beyond school: Transition from school to work (pp. 265-296).
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Wehman, P. (2001). Life beyond the
classroom: Transition strategies for young people with disabilities (3rd
ed.). Baltimore: Brookes.
Wehman, P., & Revell, W. G. (1997).
Transition into supported employment for young adults with severe
disabilities: Current practices and future directions. Journal of
Vocational Rehabilitation, 8, 65-74.
|
 |
JDPS 14:1(2003) |
|
|